Back to blogAI Search

A competitor published my Charleston SEO price

Google's AI quoted a price for my agency that I never wrote. It came from a rival's comparison list. Here is how third-party pages now describe your business.

6 min read·October 26, 2026·By Charlestowne Marketing

I run a search every Sunday to see what Google says about Charleston agencies. This week I searched "Charleston SEO companies for roofers" and found my own business sitting at number one, which was the good news. Then I read the AI answer above the results and found a dollar figure attached to my company that I have never written in that form anywhere.

The line said our residential roofing retainers are "listed at roughly $3,500 to $8,000/month."

Now, that number is correct. It is on our roofing page and has been since September. But look at the words. Our page says retainers typically run 3,500 to 8,000 dollars per month. No dollar signs, no "roughly," no "listed at." Google was not reading my sentence. It was reading somebody else's sentence about my sentence.

Where the sentence actually came from

Eight minutes of digging found it. A multi-city agency called Shellback SEO published a page titled "Best SEO Companies in Charleston, SC (2026, Ranked Honestly)." It ranks eight Charleston agencies. It ranks itself first. (To their credit, they say so out loud on the page: "We put ourselves first, and we want to be upfront about that." I respect that more than pretending the list is neutral.)

The page has a pricing column. For five of the eight agencies listed, that column reads "pricing not published." Mr. Marketing, SearchX, ClickGiant, The MediaBeast, Galileo Tech Media: no number. Fu Dog Media shows an hourly rate and a project minimum. Shellback shows its own three plans. And for us, it shows that one roofing figure, word for word the phrasing Google repeated back to me.

So the chain is: we published one number on one vertical page. A competitor scraped it into a comparison table. Google's AI read the comparison table instead of our site. A roofer in West Ashley asking a reasonable question got our most expensive number, framed by a competitor, with no context.

The part that is our fault

At this point a lot of people reading this are thinking I should be annoyed at Shellback. I am not, and I want to be clear about why.

They quoted us accurately. The number is real and it is ours. The issue is what sat next to it. Their own published plans start at 1,000 dollars a month, climb to 2,500, and top out at 4,500 for multi-market work. Ours appeared as a single range beginning at 3,500 with no floor underneath it.

Read that table as an owner with a budget. One agency has an entry point you can afford. The other starts above the first one's ceiling and apparently has nothing smaller. That is not a smear. That is an accurate reading of what we had actually published, which was a ceiling for our most contested vertical and nothing else. We gave the internet one number out of context, so one number out of context is what the internet repeated.

I have written before about how best-of lists decide Charleston AI search, and about a Charleston web design shop that published its full price list while the rest of the market stayed quiet. This is those two posts colliding. The lists are now the source AI reads, and the only thing you control is how complete your own numbers are before somebody else summarizes them.

One note on who is actually local

Worth checking before you treat any ranked list as a local guide. Shellback describes a Charleston desk, and there is a Charleston phone number on their site. There are also four others: Denver, Miami, Cheyenne, and Milwaukee, with Denver as headquarters. No street address anywhere.

That is not a crime and plenty of good work gets done remotely. But it means the page ranking Charleston agencies "honestly" is written by a company whose Charleston presence is a phone number, and Google's AI presents it alongside shops whose owners live here. If you want the longer version of why that distinction matters, I wrote it up in whether your Charleston SEO agency is actually in Charleston.

This is already happening to you

Swap the nouns. You are a Charleston plumber. A lead-gen site has a page called "best plumbers in Mount Pleasant" with your name on it, a star rating somebody computed, a response time somebody estimated, and a price range somebody inferred from a single job on a review thread. That page outranks your website for the comparison query. When a homeowner asks an AI assistant who to call, that page is the source.

You did not write it, you cannot edit it, and it is currently the most authoritative description of your pricing on the internet.

The fix is not a takedown request. It is making your own numbers complete enough that any honest summary of them is a summary you would have written yourself.

What to do this week

Four things, maybe ninety minutes total.

  1. Search your business name plus your city and read every third-party page in the top ten. Not your own site. The directories, the roundups, the comparison pages. Write down what each one claims about your prices, your service area, and your hours.
  2. Ask an AI assistant about your own category. "Best roofers in Charleston SC," "who should I call for a leak in Mount Pleasant." See whether you are named, and more importantly see which source it is paraphrasing.
  3. Find your cheapest published number and your most expensive one. If you only have an expensive one, you have the gap we had. Add a floor, a starting package, or an honest statement of the minimum job you will take.
  4. Put both ends of the range on one page. Not scattered across service pages where a scraper grabs whichever it hits first. One page, full range, with the reasoning.

I did the fourth one today. Our Charleston SEO pricing is now on a single public page with every vertical range, what drives the number up or down, and the budget floor beneath which I will tell you not to hire us. That last part is the piece I would have wanted in that comparison table, and it was nowhere, because I had never written it down in one place.

The uncomfortable lesson is that we hold number one organic for the query that started this and still lost control of the description. Ranking first bought the click. It did not buy the summary. Those are two different jobs now, and the second one is won by publishing the whole number instead of the impressive half of it.

Go read what the internet currently says you charge. It will take ten minutes and you will probably find something you need to correct.

#ai-search#charleston#pricing#service-businesses#local-seo#competitors

Want this kind of result for your business?

Free SEO audit. Two business days, no obligation, yours to keep.

Get a Free SEO Audit