Back to blogWeekly Recap

Charleston SEO Recap: The AI Answer Won (Oct 20-26)

AI Overviews now hit 83.58% of US results while the local pack sits at 19.8%. Three new studies say chasing ChatGPT is a waste for Charleston businesses.

11 min read·October 26, 2026·By Charlestowne Marketing

I pulled Semrush's Sensor up this morning to check something unrelated and ended up staring at two numbers sitting nine rows apart.

AI Overview: 83.58% of US results. Local pack: 19.8%.

That is the image on this post, read live off the tool on Sunday, not a chart somebody drew for a conference deck. The AI answer now appears on four out of five American search results. The three blue businesses in a box with a map, the thing your whole local SEO budget has been pointed at for a decade, shows up on one in five.

Then, in the same week, three separate studies landed saying the AI traffic everyone is panicking about is barely a rounding error. Both of those things are true at once, and holding them together is the whole job this week.

Five things, ranked by what they cost a Charleston business that lives off the phone ringing.

First, the AI answer is now the search result

Barry Schwartz rounded the vendor data up this morning: AI Overviews are showing on more than 80% of Google searches, up from about 50% in June of last year and roughly 15% the year before that. Semrush, SE Ranking and seoClarity all landed in the same neighborhood from different query sets.

I read the instrument myself rather than take the roundup's word for it, and the live Semrush Sensor reading for the United States was 83.58%, up 0.64 on the day. For context on the same panel: People also ask 66.99%, Video 58.24%, Sitelinks 45.15%, Reviews 36.2%, Local pack 19.8%.

SE Ranking ran a tighter test and it is the one that should bother you. They tracked 1,000 brand keywords across 17 industries, daily, October 12 through 14, cross-checked it against their own API and then hand-verified the same searches over a VPN from a US location. Result: between 82.0% and 82.7% of US brand searches returned an AI Overview, stable all three days. The same test run on Google Germany came back at 39.5% to 41.3%.

Read that again, because brand searches are not generic searches. Somebody typing your actual business name into Google now gets a Gemini-written summary of your company above your own website, roughly five times out of six. Chris Long at Nectiv flagged the branded-query surge at the end of September and it has not let up.

The German half of that study is the useful part. SE Ranking found 77% of German AI Overviews cited at least one page from the brand's own site that was not ranking in the top 10 for that search. Product pages, careers pages, support pages. And about half of all sources came from channels the brand itself manages. Germany is where the US was a few months ago, so treat that as a preview rather than a promise, but the implication for a Charleston roofer is direct: Google is pulling from your interior pages and your own profiles, not just whatever currently ranks.

What I would do this week, and it takes about ten minutes:

• Search your own business name, signed out, on your phone. Screenshot what Google says about you • Read it as a stranger would. Is the service list right? The service area? The hours? • Find the three or four interior pages Google is citing and check that they are current. Those are load-bearing now, even if they rank for nothing

I wrote in September about an AI Overview naming three Charleston plumbers for a query with no matching pages behind it. That was a curiosity then. At 83%, it is just what the results page is.

Second, three studies say stop chasing ChatGPT

Here is the part that cuts against the panic, and it landed on Thursday. Barry covered three studies published within days of each other, all pointing the same direction.

Marie Haynes looked at 100 websites and more than 145 million sessions over twelve months and found ChatGPT traffic came to 0.62% of the volume Google organic drove. Those ChatGPT visitors did convert far better, 13.8% against Google's 3.02%, about 4.5 times the rate. And it still did not matter, because Google drove 96.5% of total conversions and 27 times more conversions than every LLM combined.

SEO Works found organic delivered 39 times more traffic than AI assistants, and for every 100 conversions organic produced, AI produced 3.2. Kevin Indig looked at 12 sites across different sectors for a link between AI visibility and branded search or direct traffic and could not find one. His phrase was "not detectable yet."

At this point a lot of people are thinking: "so which is it? You just told me AI took over the results page, now you are telling me AI does not send traffic."

Both. And the resolution is the most useful sentence I can give you this week. The AI that matters is the one on Google's results page, not the one in a separate chatbot app. When somebody asks ChatGPT for a Mount Pleasant electrician, that is a trickle. When Google writes a paragraph naming electricians above the map on a search that happens ten thousand times a month in the Lowcountry, that is the business.

So my stance, and you can disagree with it: I would not spend a dollar on a "GEO" or "AI visibility" retainer sold as a separate product right now. I wrote about what ChatGPT ads actually mean for a Charleston service business earlier this year and my read has not moved. The work that gets you cited in an AI Overview is the work that was already on the list: a clear page per service, a current Google profile, real reviews, your city in your text, your phone number where a machine can read it.

Third, Google built a new front door for your business profile

This one got almost no attention and it is the biggest structural change of the week for the kind of business I work with.

Google launched Business Home, a new console that sits on top of your Business Profile. I read Google's own help docs rather than a write-up, and Google's description is: "Business Home is a growth partner built with Gemini models that connects your essential business tools." It pulls your Business Profile, Google Ads, Merchant Center and YouTube into one place, and the feature list includes AI content and photo generation, hours and review management across locations, and what Google calls "proactive growth guidance."

The eligibility rules are what made me sit up. Closed beta, select business categories, US and UK only, and you have to be the owner or manager of a verified Business Profile with fewer than 10 locations, managing only one business type, with at most one YouTube channel, one Google Ads account and one Merchant Center account. Invitations go out by email.

That is not a description of an enterprise tool. That is a Daniel Island dental practice, a West Ashley HVAC company, a Folly Beach charter operation. Google built this for the single-location Charleston service business specifically, and most of the SEO world skipped past it because it is not an algorithm story.

Two days later, Jaikishan Raturi of Wisevu and Syed Amir spotted Google testing a rebuilt Business Profile performance report, with six sections: Overview with top recommendations, Engagement, Reviews, Audience, Search Trends and Recommendations. A serious upgrade on the thin report we have now, and clearly the same project.

My honest take, since the whole point of this is giving you one: better reporting is good, and a Gemini console that writes your posts, edits your photos, and proposes your ad spend is a thing I want to watch very carefully before I let it drive. Read every recommendation before you accept it. Google's suggestions optimize for Google's inventory, and the "proactive growth guidance" in a console that also owns your Ads account is going to suggest spending money more often than it suggests not spending money. (I will take the beta invite the moment one shows up, and I will tell you exactly what it proposes.)

If you want to get in front of it, the prerequisite is boring: your profile has to be verified and in good standing, one business type, under ten locations. If you have let a second half-abandoned profile linger from an old location, clean that up now. I covered how exposed your listing already is to outside edits, and the same hygiene applies here.

Fourth, the blurb next to your link is no longer your words

Small item, real consequence. On Friday, Brodie Clark spotted Google generating the descriptions inside AI Overview citation cards rather than pulling them from the page. His words: "The text doesn't appear exactly like this on the page. It is being summarised based on the information that Google thinks is most relevant to the query."

Meta descriptions stopped being reliable years ago. This goes further. The sentence a customer reads next to your name, in the one slot you still get inside an AI answer, is now written by Google about you. You cannot write it. You can only make the underlying page say the right thing clearly enough that a summarizer cannot get it wrong.

In practice that means short declarative sentences about what you do, where, and for whom, high on the page. Not a brand story. "We repair and replace slate and metal roofs in Mount Pleasant, Sullivan's Island and Isle of Palms" is summarizer-proof. "Trusted since 1998 for all your roofing needs" is not.

Fifth, more unconfirmed volatility, and it mostly is not hitting you

Rankings got noisy again on October 20 and 21, and harder on Saturday the 24th. Schwartz reported essentially every tracker lit at once: Mozcast, Wincher, CognitiveSEO, Semrush, AWR, Serpstat, DataForSEO, Mangools, AccuRanker, SERPrecon, Zutrix, Sistrix, SimilarWeb and Algoroo.

Google has confirmed nothing. I pulled Google's own incident feed directly this morning and the newest ranking entry is still the September 2026 spam update, which ran September 24 to October 8. Nothing after it. Third unconfirmed spike this month.

Now the part worth your attention, which I have not seen anybody else point out. Semrush breaks volatility out by category, and this morning's 30-day US reading tells a clear story. All categories sat at 7.0 out of 10. But Home and Garden was 6.2. Health 6.0. Real Estate 6.2. Business and Industrial 6.9. Meanwhile Online Communities hit 8.0, Finance 7.9, Sports 7.9.

Translation for the Lowcountry: roofers, HVAC, landscapers, contractors, dentists, vets and med spas are sitting in the calmest part of the index right now. The churn is concentrated in publisher and forum territory. Three Charleston verticals are exceptions and should look harder: Autos and Vehicles at 7.8, Food and Drink at 7.8, and Law and Government at 7.5. If you run an auto shop, a restaurant or a law practice here, check your numbers this week rather than assuming you are fine.

And the caveat I owed you two weeks ago still stands. Those same trackers are the ones Google has been feeding altered results to. A category-level comparison is more trustworthy than an absolute score, because contamination should hit all categories, but I would still not make a single decision off a volatility chart this month. I have written before about how fast a Charleston SERP can change and the answer is faster than any tool reports it.

What to prioritize this week

Ranked, because these are not equally urgent:

  1. Search your own business name, signed out, right now. At 82% odds there is a Gemini summary of your company above your own link. Read what it says about you before a customer does
  2. Fix the three or four interior pages Google is citing. Services, about, contact. They are load-bearing even when they rank for nothing
  3. Rewrite your opening lines as plain declarative sentences. What you do, where, for whom. Google writes your blurb now, so make it hard to get wrong
  4. Verify your Business Profile and kill any stale duplicate listing. That is the entry requirement for Business Home, and it is overdue anyway
  5. Cancel the AI visibility retainer, if somebody sold you one. 0.62% of Google's volume. Put it into the pages above

The through-line this week, if you want one sentence: the AI answer became the search result, and the data says the way to win it is the unglamorous local work you were already supposed to be doing. That is how we work with service businesses across the Lowcountry, and if you would rather somebody audited those citation-bait pages properly than guessed at them, that is what our Mount Pleasant SEO work covers.

See you next Sunday.

#weekly-recap#ai-overviews#google-business-profile#local-seo#charleston

Want this kind of result for your business?

Free SEO audit. Two business days, no obligation, yours to keep.

Get a Free SEO Audit